choosing the best dog food at black dog barkery in bristol tennessee

Choosing the Best Dog Food: Pros and Cons of Different Types

June 24, 202513 min read

What Type of Food is Best for Your Dog?

Navigating the vast array of dog food options can be overwhelming for even the most dedicated pet owners. At Black Dog Barkery, we believe that choosing the best dog food is a crucial decision that directly impacts your canine companion's health and happiness.

This guide aims to shed light on the various types of dog food available, helping you make an informed choice for your beloved pet.

Overview of Dog Food Types

healthy dog food brands at black dog barkery

Understanding Different Types of Dog Food

When considering what to feed your dog, it's essential to understand the different types of dog food available on the market today. From traditional dry kibble to more modern raw food and gently cooked dog food options, each type of food offers unique characteristics, pros, and cons.

We'll delve into the specifics of each to help you discern which type of diet aligns best with your dog's nutritional needs and your lifestyle, ensuring you can find the best food for your dog.

The Importance of Choosing the Right Type of Dog Food

The significance of choosing the right type of dog food cannot be overstated. We've long known that our own diets have a great impact on our health and our canine companions are no different! A high-quality dog food diet is the cornerstone of your pet's overall well-being, influencing everything from their energy levels and coat health to their immune system and longevity.

Making an informed decision about the type of food you offer ensures your dog receives the proper nutrients vital for thriving. At Black Dog Barkery, we emphasize biologically appropriate foods designed to meet these your dog's unique nutritional needs.

How Dog Food Affects Your Pet's Health

The impact of your chosen dog food on your pet's health is profound. A diet lacking in essential nutrients or containing fillers can lead to a myriad of health issues, while a balanced, high-quality pet food can promote vitality and prevent common ailments.

Understanding how different dog foods affect your pet’s health will empower you to select a diet for your dog that supports their optimal well-being, making them feel their best. This knowledge is crucial for every pet owner striving for a healthy, happy canine companion.

Raw Dog Food

raw dog food black dog barkery bristol tennessee

Raw dog food has gained significant popularity among pet owners who seek a more natural and biologically appropriate diet for their canine companions. This type of dog food typically consists of uncooked meat, bones, organs, and often includes fruits and vegetables, mimicking what a dog’s ancestors might have consumed in the wild.

The philosophy behind raw dog food centers on providing a nutrient-dense diet that is minimally processed, preserving the natural enzymes and nutrients that can be lost in traditional high-heat cooking methods often used in kibble production. Many pet owners report noticeable improvements in their dog’s health and vitality when transitioning to a raw diet, making it a compelling option among different types of dog food available.

Benefits of Raw Dog Food

The benefits of raw dog food are extensive and often cited by proponents and canine nutritionists.

  • Improved digestion and nutrient absorption: Raw ingredients are in their most natural form.

  • Healthier appearance: Pet owners often observe shinier coats, healthier skin, and healthier weight.

  • Cleaner teeth: Raw diets can contribute to better dental health.

  • Increased energy levels: Dogs often have more energy when fed a raw diet.

  • Better hydration: High moisture content in raw food is beneficial, especially for dogs prone to urinary issues.

  • No fillers or artificial preservatives: The absence of these can alleviate various health concerns.

  • Avoidance of common allergens: Raw dog food can be beneficial for dogs with sensitivities.

Top Frozen Raw Dog Food Brands at Black Dog Barkery

At Black Dog Barkery, we proudly offer a selection of high-quality, frozen raw dog food options that align with our commitment to holistic pet nutrition.

  1. Tucker's: Specializes in nutrient-rich raw meat formulas that are convenient to serve, emphasizing fresh food and essential nutrients for a biologically appropriate raw food approach.

  2. Small Batch: Focuses on high-quality, fresh dog food options made with ethically sourced ingredients, promoting a raw diet that supports your dog's nutritional needs.

  3. Natural Bites Pet Food: Local to Middle TN, they offer a range of raw dog food products designed to provide a completely balanced diet for dogs.

  4. Primal: Provides a variety of raw food options, including freeze-dried and frozen varieties, ensuring your dog receives a diet primarily of raw meat with optimal nutrient content.

  5. Answers: Focuses on raw diets that are beneficial for dogs, utilizing high-quality ingredients.

Considerations and Convenience Factors

While the benefits of raw dog food are compelling, there are practical considerations and convenience factors for pet owners to weigh. 

  • Raw food requires careful handling and storage to prevent bacterial contamination.

  • Proper refrigeration and hygiene are paramount.

  • Raw dog food has a shorter shelf life once thawed.

  • Needs to be consumed relatively quickly.

  • More expensive than traditional kibble.

For most owners who want a more biologically appropriate diet for their dogs, these considerations are easily overcome but do take some extra planning (hello freezer space!). For those than need a more flexible or shelf stable option, but still want a high-quality and biologically appropriate diet, don't worry! 

We've got options for you too!

Kibble: The Traditional Option

dog food at black dog barkery

Pros and Cons of Kibble

Kibble, or dry dog food, has long been the most common type of dog food available, favored for its convenience and long shelf life.

Pros

  • Affordability and ease of storage

  • Does not require refrigeration

  • Can be left out for longer periods without spoiling

Cons

  • High percentage of fillers like corn, wheat, and soy

  • Lower nutritional value

  • Can be difficult for some dogs to digest

  • Highly processed, leading to loss of vital nutrients

Top Kibble Brands at Black Dog Barkery

While Black Dog Barkery primarily champions fresh and raw food diets, we know that some pet owners prefer the convenience and cost of kibble. We meticulously select the dry food brands we carry, ensuring they meet higher standards than conventional commercial dog food.

We've found that Open Farm offers a high-quality kibble option and even offers a Raw Mix option that combines the convenience of kibble with the addition of freeze-dried raw morsels effectively upping the nutrition value of your pups meal!

Convenience vs. Nutritional Value

The choice between kibble and other types of dog food often boils down to a balance between convenience and nutritional value. Dry kibble is undeniably convenient for pet owners due to its ease of storage and feeding, making it a practical option for busy lifestyles.

However, this convenience often comes at the expense of optimal nutrition. Many dry dog food products undergo extensive processing, which can degrade the quality of ingredients and reduce the bioavailability of nutrients. Additionally, many kibble options are very high in carbohydrates which isn't as biologically appropriate as diets higher in protein.

While Black Dog Barkery offers select, higher-quality kibble options, we always encourage pet owners to consider fresh food, raw food, or gently cooked dog food diets for superior health benefits, even if they require a bit more effort.

Freeze-Dried and Air-Dried Dog Food

freeze-dried raw food at black dog barkery bristol virginia

What is Freeze-Dried Dog Food?

Freeze-dried dog food represents an innovative and increasingly popular type of dog food that bridges the gap between the convenience of dry food and the nutritional benefits of raw food. The freeze-drying process involves freezing raw ingredients and then removing their moisture content through a vacuum, preserving nearly all the natural nutrients, enzymes, and flavors found in raw meat, organs, and produce.

This gentle method avoids high heat, which can destroy delicate vitamins and minerals present in other types of pet food. The resulting freeze-dried food is lightweight, shelf-stable, and incredibly palatable, making it an excellent option for pet owners seeking a convenient yet nutrient-dense raw diet for their dog.

Pros of Freeze-Dried Dog Food

Unlike it's frozen raw counterpart, freeze-dried raw diets are incredibly easy to feed, especially for those used to feeding a kibble diet. Convenience isn't the only item in the pro column for this type of dog food though: 

  • Retains much of the nutritional integrity of fresh ingredients

  • Minimizes nutrient degradation

  • Highly palatable and digestible for dogs

  • Improves coat health

  • Enhances digestion

  • Increases energy

  • Does not require refrigeration

  • Less rigorous handling compared to fresh raw diets

Top Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Food Brands at Black Dog Barkery

At Black Dog Barkery, we proudly stock leading brands of freeze-dried and air-dried dog food that exemplify our commitment to superior nutrition.

  • Open Farm: Offers dehydrated raw food made with ethically sourced ingredients, providing a fresh, nutritious diet for your dog that’s beneficial compared to traditional kibble.

  • Tucker's: Specializes in raw dog food options that prioritize high-quality raw meat, ensuring your dog receives optimal nutrients and a diet that mimics natural feeding.

  • Vital Essentials: Provides freeze-dried raw food that retains the moisture content of fresh food, making it a convenient choice for dog owners wanting to feed their pets a raw diet with long shelf life.

  • Primal Pet Foods: Focuses on biologically appropriate raw food, combining the benefits of raw with easy-to-use formats, making it a great option for pet owners looking for the right food for their dogs.

Cooked Dog Food Options

fresh dog food at black dog barkery tricities TN VA

Understanding Gently Cooked and Fresh Dog Food

Gently cooked dog food and fresh dog food represent another excellent alternative to highly processed kibble, offering a balance between the nutritional benefits of raw diets and the convenience and safety often associated with cooked meals.

This type of dog food involves lightly cooking whole, human-grade ingredients at low temperatures, which helps to preserve the natural nutrients while reducing concerns about pathogens sometimes associated with raw meat.

These fresh food options are often prepared in small batches, ensuring quality and freshness, and typically contain high-quality proteins, healthy fats, and a variety of vegetables and fruits. The minimal processing makes these types of dog food highly digestible and palatable, providing a nutrient-rich diet for your dog that many pet owners find beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs or picky eaters.

Homemade Dog Food: Pros and Cons

If you're up for an adventure, you can also prepare your dogs food at home. This takes quite a bit of planning but also gives you complete control over the ingredients, ensuring a diet free from fillers, artificial preservatives, and common allergens often found in commercial dog food.

The pros of homemade dog food include tailoring meals to your dog's specific nutritional needs, such as managing allergies or supporting particular health conditions. However, the cons involve the significant time commitment required for preparation and, crucially, the challenge of ensuring a nutritionally complete and balanced diet.

Without expert guidance from a canine nutritionist or veterinarian, homemade dog food can easily lack essential nutrients, leading to deficiencies over time. Therefore, while offering ultimate customization, careful planning and professional consultation are paramount to make homemade dog food a truly beneficial type of food for your dog.

Top Fresh and Gently Cooked Dog Foods at Black Dog Barkery

For pet owners seeking the convenience of prepared fresh food without the commitment of homemade dog food, Black Dog Barkery offers exceptional gently cooked dog food options that meet high nutritional standards.

  1. Open Farm: gently cooked dog food that uses human-grade ingredients to create balanced meals, ensuring optimal nutrition and ease of feeding for dog owners. 

  2. Small Batch: gently cooked diets that focus on whole ingredients and minimal processing.

Finding the Best Food for Your Dog

best dog foods black dog barkery

Identifying Food Allergies and Dietary Needs

Identifying food allergies and specific dietary needs is a critical step in choosing the best food for your dog, as a tailored type of food can significantly improve their health and quality of life. Common signs of food allergies include itching, digestive upset, ear infections, and skin issues.

If you suspect your dog has an allergy, consulting with your veterinarian is essential to conduct elimination diets or other diagnostic tests. Understanding your dog's unique nutritional needs—whether due to age, activity level, breed-specific requirements, or existing health conditions—will guide you toward the most appropriate type of dog food.

Feel free to stop by Black Dog Barkery so we can help you in navigating these considerations, helping you select a diet for your dog that addresses their specific sensitivities and promotes overall well-being. 

How to Choose the Best Food for Your Dog

Choosing the best food for your dog involves considering individual factors such as age, breed, activity level, and any pre-existing health conditions. For instance, puppies require different nutrient ratios for growth, while senior dogs benefit from joint support and easily digestible formulas.

Highly active dogs may need more calories and protein, whereas less active or overweight dogs benefit from lower-calorie, high-fiber options. Dogs with sensitivities might thrive on novel protein or limited ingredient diets.

At Black Dog Barkery, we emphasize personalized recommendations, guiding pet owners through our diverse selection of raw food, gently cooked dog food, and freeze-dried dog food options to find the best type of diet that supports each dog's unique requirements, ensuring they receive the dog food that's optimal for their specific needs.

Final Recommendations from Black Dog Barkery

At Black Dog Barkery, our ultimate recommendation for choosing the best dog food centers on providing a biologically appropriate raw food or fresh food diet whenever possible. We firmly believe that raw dog food, gently cooked dog food, and freeze-dried dog food options offer the most comprehensive nutritional benefits, promoting optimal health, vitality, and longevity for your canine companion.

While we acknowledge the convenience of certain kibble options, our top choices for pet owners seeking the very best food for their dog are found within our curated selection of Open Farm Pets, Tucker's Raw and Frozen Treats, Answer's, Primal Pet Foods, Small Batch Pet Food, Vital Essentials, and Stella & Chewy's. These brands represent the pinnacle of quality in the pet food industry, aligning with our commitment to superior nutrition.

Questions? Stop by and see us! We offer a VIP program for select customers that unlocks year round discounts on the products that you already purchase!

Black Dog Barkery is your go to shop for holistic pet care. Come check out our high quality dog food options at our store in Bristol, Tennessee.

Black Dog Barkery

Black Dog Barkery is your go to shop for holistic pet care. Come check out our high quality dog food options at our store in Bristol, Tennessee.

Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog